Monday, August 13, 2018

Magneto Vs. Plastic Man


This I think could be a pretty interesting battle.  Usually Magneto has the upper hand when fighting a hero due to his incredibly powerful skill set, but Plastic Man's unique composition would not lend itself to outside manipulation.  Then you have their disparate personalities to consider, action with a smile versus dead serious extreme activism - it would definitely be a fun match up to watch play out.

21 comments:

The Grey Man said...

Fantastic idea there, Magneto gets his butt kicked for sure, although are we sure Plastic Man has no metal in his body at all?

Ross said...

I've never seen him bleed - I think he's pliable plastic through and through.

MarchHareSupreme said...

But wait.-,,Plas would still have iron molecules in his system. See xmen 2 for an idea of what could happen .

TJW said...

I was going to point out that Maggie could still drop every car in a ten mile radius on top of Plas which would not kill him, but would surely slow him down. Then I noticed the barren landscape, and I realized that you'd already thought of that! Bravo, Sir, for being one step ahead!

It then occurred to me that they are fighting in a polar setting which gives a double meaning to the title. Bravo again, Sir! I assume that they are fighting near the North Pole which is made up of snow and ice and no land and is therefore lacking in metal in the natural environment.

And before some wise guy points out that Plas becomes less fluid and elastic in an extremely cold environment, I'm going to take the liberty of suggesting that he's wearing his Plas thermal underwear.

(Now I'm wondering if there is such a thing as an Earth-STF No-Prize.)

Glenn said...

The environment certainly gives Eel an advantage as long as Magneto cannot seize him by iron molecules in his blood and since he is capable of reproducing he likely has them.

Carycomic said...

@TJW: unless, of course, they're fighting at the North Magnetic Pole (which would give Herr Lenscher quite the energy boost). If so, Mr. O'Brian would most likely get his Plas kicked!*

*Oops! Somehow posted this in triplicate. Consider the first two copies deleted.

TJW said...

I wasn't aware that Magneto derived his powers from the Earth's magnetic poles. And if he doesn't, why would being near the magnetic north pole give him "quite the energy boost"?

Carycomic said...

There was an an Avengers tussle with the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants back in the early 1970's. Following their defeat of the latter, the Avengers imprisoned Magneto in a plastic bubble underground, equidistant between the North and South Magnetic Poles. If that could neutralize his powers, it stands to reason just being at one spot or the other would have the (ahem!) polar opposite effect.

Carycomic said...

"That's my theory and I'm stickin' to it." :-)

Anonymous said...

Considering that Magneto is getting his ass kicked on this cover, I'd say that your theory is incorrect, Cary Comic.

Anonymous said...

Was Magneto Marvel's answer to Dr. Polaris, or did he come first?

Jay Johnson said...

Anon: It looks like they were both created at about the same time, possibly inspired by something in the news. Dr. Polaris saw print first (June 1963) but Magneto (Sept. 1963) was right behind. Of course, both were preceded by Cosmic Boy of the Legion (1957), and there were Golden Age magnetic characters, including The Human Magnet (1-shot Batman villian, 1952) and The Magnet (hero, 1944).

Simreeve said...

and 'Magno', at Quality comics, was even earlier than those...

Anonymous said...

@Anonymous #1---Not necessarily, dude. Look how often real-world covers depicted the villain kicking the hero's butt! Only for the reverse to prove true within the book, of course.

A similar reversal could just as plausibly occur, here. After all; even TV news weathercasters can't be wrong all the time!---Cary

Anonymous said...

Uh... Cary, you do understand that there is no book, right?

Carycomic said...

Doesn't mean I should give up hoping.

Who knows? This might even be the year Miss America's wish for world peace finally comes true!

Btw: is it true that Amelia Earhart and Jimmy Hoffa were seen together at Studio 54, recently?

Anonymous said...

[...while quietly speed-dialing for the men in white coats]


Oooooooooookay! On a lighter note, Ross, how about Johnny Thunder meets Lionel Ritchie? Just so you could entitle it...

"Cei-U, Say Me!"

Carycomic said...

Now, THAT is a real-world published team-up I'd buy in a New Yawk minute!

Daviticus said...

*ahem* Only one quotation mark.

Anonymous said...

Oh, dear! Daviticus is right.

The quote marks to the left of the P are missing!

I guess Anonymous #1 was wrong. Magneto ain't as helpless as he looks.

Anonymous said...

No because down to every last molecule he is plastic.. otherwise he will be able to shape shift stretch or regenerate body parts at will.

Support STF: The Lost Issues!